
Head to head
HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw vs. Epson Workforce ES-580W
Deciding between an all-in-one printer and a dedicated document scanner.
Gadgetrize editorialNov 8, 20264 min
The All-in-One vs. The Dedicated Specialist Choosing between the HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw and the Epson Workforce ES-580W comes down to your desire for integration versus specialization. The HP is an all-in-one unit that covers printing, scanning, and copying. The Epson is a standalone high-speed document scanner that specializes in digitizing paper as quickly as possible. When you look at the HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw, you are looking at a machine meant to handle the complete cycle of a document. The Epson, meanwhile, is designed to kill paper trails by moving everything into your digital storage system. ## Performance Differences That Matter The Epson Workforce ES-580W is significantly faster at feeding stacks of paper and turning them into PDFs than the scanning function on the HP. Because it is a dedicated piece of hardware, the Epson includes specialized rollers and software meant to handle double-sided scanning at high speeds without jams. The HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw scans well enough for occasional use, but it is not optimized for thousands of pages of archival work. Conversely, the Epson cannot print. If you choose the scanner, you must maintain your existing printer or rely on others for your output needs. The HP solves your printing, copying, and scanning needs in a single package. ## When the Epson Wins The Epson Workforce ES-580W wins if your primary focus is paperless transition. If you have boxes of old documents and you need to get them onto a hard drive, the HP will be a bottleneck. The dedicated scanner is built for high-throughput digitizing. If you are already happy with your current printer or have a small ink-jet machine that you do not mind using for occasional printing, adding the Epson makes more sense than replacing everything with an all-in-one. The HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw wins if you have no current printer or your existing unit has failed, and you need a single machine to handle all common office tasks. ## Final Strategy The HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw provides the flexibility to create and record documents, while the Epson offers superior recording speed at the expense of creation. Look at your desk and decide if you need to print more or scan more. If you need a bit of everything in a reliable monochrome package, the HP is the path. You can see the live price on Amazon. If you want to purge your paper clutter, look to the Epson instead.
The bottom line
Ready for the HP LaserJet MFP M235sdw | Monochrome | Laser Printer | All-in-One | Duplex?
The live price and today's availability are on the Amazon listing.
Buy it on Amazon