
Head to Head: Sony BDP-S1700U Full HD 1080p Blu-ray DVD Player with HDMI Cable vs Philips BDP1502
We compare a standard playback device against a model that features proprietary upscaling capabilities.
Framing the Decision
When you weigh the Sony BDP-S1700U Full HD 1080p Blu-ray DVD Player with HDMI Cable against the Philips BDP1502, the decision is framed around how your player handles older, lower-resolution content. The Sony BDP-S1700U Full HD 1080p Blu-ray DVD Player with HDMI Cable is a reliable worker, but the Philips alternative makes specific claims regarding DVD upscaling to HD quality. This is the crux of the comparison: do you care about how your non-Blu-ray discs look on a modern screen?
Specifications and Features
The Philips BDP1502 includes upscaling technology intended to make standard definition DVDs look clearer on your 1080p display. While the Sony unit is highly capable, its focus remains on native Blu-ray playback. If your library consists largely of older discs that were never remastered, the Philips hardware claims to bridge that gap through its upscaling engine. Both players include the necessary HDMI cables, so you are ready to connect to your television immediately regardless of which brand you select.
When the Alternative Wins
The Philips alternative wins when you prioritize the presentation of your older, standard-definition collection. If your collection is a mix of new Blu-rays and older DVDs, you might find the image enhancement on the Philips to be a tangible benefit. The Sony unit remains a better choice if you value consistency and the proven track record of the Sony interface. The Philips, being a renewed model, adds another layer to your shopping process, as you must verify the condition of the refurbished components before you hit the buy button.
- Sony relies on proven, stable performance
- Philips emphasizes upscaling for legacy discs
- Both include HDMI cables for out-of-the-box utility
Final Comparison
Choosing between these two depends on whether you want a player that treats every disc as a standard file or a player that tries to refine the older ones. Check the live price on Amazon for both models. If the Philips is available at a lower price point, the upscaling feature becomes a significant bonus for your older DVD library. However, for those who prefer the simplicity of a new Sony device and have a library primarily composed of HD content, the Sony remains the standard against which others are measured.
The bottom line
Ready for the Sony BDP-S1700U Full HD 1080p Blu-ray DVD Player with HDMI Cable?
The live price and today's availability are on the Amazon listing.
Buy it on Amazon